The Abortion Controversy : ISBN 978-1-6782-0772-4 / eBook: 978-1-6782-0773-1
American Society of Journalists and Authors, 2025 award for Children/Young Adult Nonfiction
, September 8, 2025
Winner of the American Society of Journalists and Authors (ASJA) award for best Children/Young Adult Nonfiction of the 2025.
The short book explains the major issues in the complex history of the abortion issue in the U.S. The sidebars, graphs, photos, charts and map make for a balanced visual effect and the interviews present an engaging read. The work is a valuable contribution to a Young Adult library and broadens the reader’s understanding of issues in the wider world.
The Abortion Controversy : ISBN 978-1-6782-0772-4 / eBook: 978-1-6782-0773-1
Booklist, September 20, 2024
Whether for debate studies or personal exploration, this volume presents a balanced and detailed overview of the nation’s abortion controversy. In particular, it considers the
repercussions following the 2022 U.S. Supreme Court ruling in the case of Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, which decided that there is no constitutional right to an abortion. Individual chapters in straightforward text, supplemented by quotes and facts from both pro-life and pro-choice individuals, politicians, and organizations, explain Roe v. Wade and the path to overturn it, as well as health care access and concerns for women and medical professionals’ responsibilities under the Dobbs ruling. The last two chapters focus, respectively, on antiabortion crusaders and their pro-life movements and legislative efforts by pro-choice advocates to restore abortion rights. Interspersed photos, charts, graphs, and sidebars (e.g., one covers the woman who became known as the plaintiff Jane Roe) add context to the multifaceted information, making this complex issue more accessible. Readers can continue their research through the extensive back matter, including source notes and related organizations, books, and websites.
— Angela Leeper
The Abortion Controversy : ISBN 978-1-6782-0772-4 / eBook: 978-1-6782-0773-1
Kirkus Reviews, September 1, 2024
An overview that presents a contentious topic in a clear and dispassionate light.
The introduction describes the state of abortion rights in the U.S. in the wake of the 2022 Supreme Court decision in Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization, which rescinded Roe v. Wade, the historic 1973 case that legalized abortion. The first chapter recounts the historical context, starting from the early 19th century. Two subsequent chapters focus on risks to women and medical professionals as a result of abortion restrictions. The two final chapters present current efforts to completely ban abortion and the opposing drive to restore abortion rights. Short narratives depict and quote people who have been affected by the Dobbs ruling, showing the emotional impact and medical hazards of pregnancy complications and limited health care access. Relatedly, the book describes the “sizable segment of women” who are avoiding pregnancy “because they are fearful that Dobbs robs them of the health care...they require.” Textboxes present relevant background information, such as the story of the actual Jane Roe. Graphs, charts, and photographs break up the text. Lerose describes anti-abortion groups' embrace of “the personhood of every fetus,” highlighting the spread of student groups. Disappointingly, the book doesn’t connect positions on abortion with various religious teachings, and some complex information, such as the possible mental health impact of abortion, is presented without sufficient context. Nevertheless, this is an accessible and timely resource.
A brief, balanced overview of a fraught and complex issue. (source notes, organizations, for further research, index, picture credits) (Nonfiction. 13-18)